In this story, as the chief character is internally melodramatic, the story itself ceases to be merely melodramatic, and partakes of true dreams
- T.S. Eliot
Like Poe before him and Conan Doyle after, Wilkie Collins shifted easily from rational domains to the "supernatural". Like them, he is famed for original contributions to "ratiocinative" (detective) literature, but often preferred to indulge his occult predilection - a lifelong indulgence. His first published story The Last Stage Coach Man
(1843) was a supernatural allegory of trains; perhaps his last lucid effort (before ill health and opium drained his powers) was his short novel, The Haunted Hotel
Collins' methods and themes, developed and elaborated in his earlier, massive novels, are streamlined and concentrated here into a tight novelette. The same relentless pace and narrative power, the same attention to plot and backdrop detail that distinguish The Moonstone
and The Woman in White
are evident here, as is the obsession with destiny and willful struggle against it.
Collins' much-loved Venice provides the scenery and fatal beauty, the grim waterways and palaces the author will haunt with mysterious woman, grotesques and bloody conspiracies. The Countess Narona is one of Collins' cosmopolitan enchantresses; she acts, but as a tool of her doom. T.S. Eliot wrote, The principal character, the fatal woman, is herself obsessed by the idea of fatality; her motives are melodramatic; she therefore compels the coincidences to occur, feeling that she is compelled to compel them.
Collins relieves the tension with some wry characterizations and ironies; the theatrics are sustained. Indeed, theatrical motifs figure heavily, Collins himself being heavily involved with the stage at that period.The Haunted Hotel
appears to be loosely based upon a case from teh annals of French crime; the scene, scenery, players and conflicts, and especially the horror, come straight from Collins' overstimulated, no doubt overwrought, most certainly haunted imagination.